Logo

City Council
Agenda Report

ITEM NO. 16
 
 
DATE:
November 18, 2026
 
FROM:
Todd Hileman, City Manager
 
PREPARED BY:

Nick Kimball, Assistant City Manager/Chief Financial Officer

 
SUBJECT:

CONSIDERATION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 8044 SUPPORTING JOINT ADVOCACY BY THE FOOTHILL CITIES TO THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY REGARDING FARE ENFORCEMENT, FAREGATE INSTALLATION, AND SECURITY AT METRO A-LINE STATIONS

 

Recommendation

It is recommended that the City Council:

 

  1. Adopt Resolution No. 8044 supporting joint advocacy by the Foothill Cities to the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Metro) regarding fare enforcement, faregate installation, and security at Metro A Line stations; and
  2. Authorize the Mayor to sign the joint statement to the Metro Board of Directors in substantially the form attached.
 
Executive Summary

Ten cities with Metro A Line stations (Arcadia, Azusa, Duarte, Glendora, Irwindale, La Verne, Monrovia, Pasadena, San Dimas, and South Pasadena) have drafted a joint letter to the Board of Directors of the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Attachment 2). The letter requests three actions: 1) installation of faregates serving the A Line at Union Station; 2) a Metro-funded, expedited plan to install faregates at A Line stations in the participating cities; and 3) Metro-led fare enforcement and security applied consistently at all A Line platforms.


The letter is meant to be signed by the mayor of each participating city. The City’s Legislative Advocacy Policy provides that positions not expressly covered by the adopted Legislative Platform are brought to the City Council for direction. The proposed resolution would establish the City’s position on the three requests and authorize the Mayor to sign the letter.

 
Background

On July 26, 2003, the South Pasadena Station opened on July 26, 2003, as part of the Metro Gold Line between Union Station and Pasadena. The line was later designated the L Line and, following completion of the Regional Connector in 2023, became part of the A Line. The A Line was extended to Pomona on September 19, 2025.


In February 2017, the Metro Board approved a multi-agency law enforcement contract under which the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, the Los Angeles Police Department, and the Long Beach Police Department provide policing on the bus and rail system. The Sheriff’s Department is the contracted agency for stations outside the cities of Los Angeles and Long Beach.


On June 21, 2017, the South Pasadena City Council requested that a letter be sent to Metro regarding the visibility of law enforcement on the rail line and buses serving South Pasadena. 


On December 1, 2021, the City Council unanimously approved a letter to the Metro Board opposing a recommendation from an ad hoc committee of Metro’s Public Safety Advisory Committee to end contracted law enforcement on the system and reallocate approximately $75 million to non-law enforcement alternatives (Attachment 3). The letter referenced the limited visibility of law enforcement on trains and at stations, requested an accounting of law enforcement deployment along the L Line, and expressed support for a transit ambassador program. The Metro Board subsequently approved $75.2 million in additional contract authority for law enforcement services.


In 2022 and 2023, Metro launched its Transit Ambassador program, placing unarmed staff on trains and at stations.


On June 27, 2024, the Metro Board approved an implementation plan to establish an in-house transit public safety department, since named the Metro Department of Public Safety, to be phased in over several years.


On February 27, 2025, the Metro Board established a $15.3 million project budget to install taller faregates at eleven (11) additional stations, following a first phase of ten (10) stations funded at $14.4 million. The South Pasadena Station was not included in either phase.


In February 2026, Metro staff reported to the Metro Board’s Operations, Safety, and Customer Experience Committee that A Line stations with taller faregates recorded a 32 percent decrease in violent crime and a 7 percent decrease in property crime, while the A Line as a whole recorded a 10 percent increase in violent crime over the same period.


In November 2026, the Foothill Cities circulated a draft joint letter for signature by each city’s mayor.

 
Analysis

Regional transportation agencies like Metro plan, fund, and operate systems that cross many jurisdictions, and decisions made at the agency level on fare enforcement, station access, and security affect each host city in similar ways. A single city has limited standing to influence systemwide policy, and separate requests from individual cities can produce station-by-station responses that differ along the same line. A coordinated response allows the affected cities to present a common set of facts and a single set of requests, which gives the agency’s governing board a consistent basis for action and reduces the likelihood that conditions addressed at one station move to another. 

 

Joint action also documents that the costs local agencies are absorbing, including police personnel time and the potential use of local return funds, are shared across the corridor and are not specific to one community. For these reasons, staff at the cities that host Metro A Line stations have prepared a joint letter to the Metro Board of Directors, and the City Council is asked to consider the City’s participation and to establish a City position, by resolution, on the three requests the letter makes of Metro.

 

The joint letter makes three requests to Metro: 

 

  1. Install and enforce faregates serving the A Line at Union Station;
  2. Expedite a plan for faregates at A Line stations in the participating cities, where physically and operationally feasible, funded by Metro; and
  3. Enhance Metro-led fare enforcement and security and apply enforcement consistently at all platforms.

 

The proposed letter highlights that the A Line platform at Union Station is not gated while all the other rail lines are, which makes the A-Line the easiest for riders to access without paying a fare.  In response to requests to install fare gates, Metro has suggested cities consider using local return funds for faregate installation. The City receives local return allocations under Proposition A, Proposition C, Measure R, and Measure M and programs them for local transit, street, and mobility purposes. 

 

This position by Metro creates a significant inequity for cities with light rail stations as they are expected to divert local return funds while cities without a light rail station are not saddled with that same financial burden and may use those funds for street and sidewalk infrastructure improvements, among other uses.  It should be noted that local return funds are based on population and cities with a Metro station do not receive more funding than those without.

 

With regards to public safety, the South Pasadena Police Department has responded to more than 25 calls for service since January 2026, primarily related to property crimes.  Additionally, the Los Angeles Sherriff’s Department (LASD) Transit Services Bureau has reported four (4) crimes at the South Pasadena Station in 2026.

 

Adoption of the proposed Resolution would place the City on record with the other A-Line cities and authorize the Mayor’s signature. It states the City’s position on the three requests and aligns with the adopted Legislative Platform positions on regional cost-shifting, protection of local transportation funding, and public safety; is consistent with the City Council’s December 2021 communication to Metro; and is being advanced jointly with the other cities that host A Line stations. 

 

If the City does not participate, it is anticipated that the letter would proceed without South Pasadena’s signature.

 
Fiscal Impact

There is no fiscal impact associated with adoption of the resolution or signature of the joint letter. No appropriation is requested, and staff time for coordination is included within the adopted Fiscal Year 2026-27 City Manager’s Office Work Plan.

 
Attachment:
Attachment No. 1 - Resolution No. 8044
Attachment No. 2 - Letter to Metro DRAFT
Attachment No. 3 - December 1, 2021 City Council Letter to Metro