Roger Sung, Human Resources Director
CONSIDERATION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION 8042 TO UPDATE THE DEPUTY CITY CLERK JOB DESCRIPTION, SALARY RANGE, EXEMPT STATUS, AND BARGAINING UNIT REPRESENTATION
It is recommended that the City Council adopt Resolution No. 8042 approving the revised Deputy City Clerk classification specification, changing its designation from Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) non-exempt to exempt, removing the classification from the Public Service Employees Association (PSEA) bargaining unit, and placing the classification within the City's unrepresented management group, including approval of the associated salary range.
The City recently conducted a review of the Deputy City Clerk classification following the vacancy of the position after an internal staff promotion. The review resulted in recommendations to update the classification specification, change its Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) designation from non-exempt to exempt, adjust the salary range to reflect market competitiveness, and remove the classification from the Public Service Employees Association (PSEA) bargaining unit for placement within the City's unrepresented management group.
As part of the meet-and-confer process, the City provided PSEA with a written justification on October 16, 2026, and met with Union representatives on October 19, 2026, to discuss the proposed changes and address questions. On October 20, 2026, PSEA communicated its concurrence with the revised classification specification, FLSA exempt designation, and modification to bargaining unit representation.
With the meet-and-confer process completed and PSEA's concurrence obtained, City Council approval is now requested to formally authorize the proposed classification changes, revised salary range, and placement within the unrepresented management group. Approval of the accompanying resolution will allow the City to implement the changes and proceed with recruitment under the updated classification structure.
The existing Deputy City Clerk classification specification was developed more than twenty years ago and required relevant updates to adequately capture the full scope, complexity, and accountability of the position. While the classification has historically been represented by PSEA and designated as FLSA non-exempt, the City's review identified responsibilities more consistent with a management-level classification. Additionally, a compensation study was conducted to determine if the Deputy City Clerk position was competitive to neighboring agencies and assist with recruitment efforts given the broader scope of responsibility that requires more discretion, independence, and authority in enhancing the existing programs.
The recent vacancy of the position due to an internal promotion provided an appropriate opportunity to evaluate and revise the job specification before proceeding with recruitment. Updating the classification at this time ensures that prospective candidates have a clear understanding of the position's expectations, minimum qualifications, level of authority, and organizational responsibilities.
The City Clerk's Office is responsible for a broad range of statutory, administrative, and legislative functions that are essential to the City's daily operations and adherence to applicable laws and regulations. These responsibilities include City Council agenda administration, maintenance of official City records, coordination of municipal elections, administration of public records requests, records retention, and other legally mandated functions.
The City Clerk’s Office operates with a limited staffing structure consisting of the Chief City Clerk and Deputy City Clerk. As a result, the Deputy City Clerk plays a significant role in the administration, coordination, and management of departmental functions and is expected to maintain operational continuity in the absence of the Chief City Clerk.
Human Resources, in collaboration with the City Clerk’s Office, reviewed the Deputy City Clerk classification to evaluate its duties, qualifications, compensation, FLSA designation, and bargaining unit representation. The following summarizes the review process and methodology used to develop the proposed recommendations.
Process and Methodology
The review included an assessment of the existing classification specification, current and anticipated responsibilities, organizational structure, minimum qualifications, FLSA requirements, and compensation practices among neighboring municipalities.
Particular attention was given to the level of independent judgment, decision-making authority, responsibility for managing assigned programs, and the degree of accountability associated with the position.
Human Resources also conducted a compensation comparison involving neighboring municipalities in the San Gabriel Valley and surrounding areas, including Arcadia, Alhambra, Glendale, Pasadena, Temple City, San Marino, Monterey Park, San Gabriel, and Monrovia. The review considered comparable classifications, assigned responsibilities, minimum qualifications, reporting relationships, and salary ranges, recognizing that classification titles and organizational structures may differ among agencies.
In addition, the City evaluated the classification under the applicable FLSA administrative exemption criteria and considered whether the position's responsibilities and community of interest remained appropriately aligned with the PSEA bargaining unit.
Meet-and-Confer Process
Recognizing that the proposed modifications involved changes to an existing represented classification, the City engaged PSEA in the meet-and-confer process.
On October 16, 2026, the City provided PSEA with a detailed justification memorandum outlining the basis for the proposed revisions, including the expanded duties and responsibilities, FLSA exempt designation, and proposed modification to bargaining unit representation.
On October 19, 2026, representatives from the City and PSEA met to review the justification memorandum and discuss the City's recommendations. During the meeting, the City explained the operational and organizational considerations supporting the proposed changes and responded to questions raised by PSEA.
At the conclusion of the meeting, PSEA indicated that it would further discuss the proposals internally before communicating its position.
On October 20, 2026, PSEA communicated its concurrence with all three proposed changes:
- Approval of the revised Deputy City Clerk job specification.
- Modification of the classification's FLSA designation from non-exempt to exempt.
- Removal of the classification from the PSEA bargaining unit and placement within the City's unrepresented management group.
The Parties' understanding is to be memorialized through a Memorandum of Agreement documenting the outcome of the discussions and the agreed-upon modifications, subject to applicable approval and implementation requirements.
Findings and Evaluation
Based on the classification review, Human Resources identified several findings supporting the proposed modifications.
1. Revised Job Specification and Expanded Management Responsibilities
The revised classification specification more accurately defines the level of responsibility, independence, and accountability required of the Deputy City Clerk.
The position is responsible for administering and managing assigned components of the City Clerk's operations, including legislative processes, public records requests, municipal elections, records management, and other statutory functions.
In addition to performing technical and administrative work, the Deputy City Clerk is expected to independently evaluate complex issues, interpret and implement applicable policies and procedures, establish operational priorities, recommend process improvements, and resolve matters requiring professional judgment. The classification also provides administrative guidance to other City departments and assumes the responsibilities of the Chief City Clerk during their absence. These responsibilities extend beyond routine clerical or technical functions and reflect a higher level of program management, independent judgment, and organizational accountability. The revised minimum qualifications also establish more appropriate educational and professional experience requirements consistent with the complexity of the position.
2. FLSA Exempt Designation
Human Resources conducted a separate evaluation of the Deputy City Clerk classification under the FLSA administrative exemption criteria established in 29 Code of Federal Regulations (C.F.R.) § 541.200.
To qualify for the administrative exemption, a position must satisfy three primary requirements: (1) compensation on a salary basis at or above the applicable minimum threshold; (2) primary duties consisting of office or non-manual work directly related to management or general business operations; and (3) the exercise of discretion and independent judgment concerning matters of significance.
Salary Requirement: The proposed minimum monthly salary of $8,968 exceeds the applicable federal salary threshold for the administrative exemption. The position will be compensated on a salary basis consistent with FLSA requirements.
Nature of the Work: The Deputy City Clerk's primary responsibilities involve the administration of governmental, legislative, regulatory, and departmental functions. These include Public Records Act administration, municipal elections, City Council and commission processes, official records management, statutory filings and notices, and oversight of departmental procedures. These functions are directly related to the City's general governmental operations and extend beyond routine clerical or technical duties.
Discretion and Independent Judgment: The classification requires the independent evaluation of complex administrative and regulatory matters, interpretation and implementation of policies and procedures, establishment of operational priorities, coordination with City departments, and identification and resolution of compliance concerns. The position operates under general supervision and is expected to recommend or determine appropriate courses of action within its delegated authority.
Based on the evaluation, Human Resources determined that the revised Deputy City Clerk classification aligns with the requirements of the FLSA administrative exemption. This determination is based on the position's primary duties and expected exercise of independent judgment, rather than its title, salary level, or attendance at City Council meetings alone. Accordingly, staff recommends changing the classification's FLSA designation from non-exempt to exempt, consistent with the actual duties and responsibilities assigned to the position.
3. Bargaining Unit Representation and Community of Interest
Human Resources also evaluated the Deputy City Clerk's bargaining unit placement under the City's Employer-Employee Relations Resolution No. 7597 and the community-of-interest principles applicable under the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act (MMBA).
Resolution No. 7597 defines a Management Employee as an employee responsible for formulating, administering, or managing the implementation of City policies and programs. Additionally, Section 10 establishes criteria for determining appropriate bargaining units, including the similarity of duties, qualifications, working conditions, organizational structure, community of interest, and managerial or supervisory responsibilities.
This evaluation considered the classification's responsibilities, level of independent authority, management accountability, reporting relationship, and participation in departmental administration and decision-making. The Deputy City Clerk exercises substantial discretion in managing assigned programs, provides guidance on administrative and regulatory matters, and assumes responsibility for City Clerk operations in the absence of the Chief City Clerk. Given these responsibilities, the City determined that the position's community of interest is more closely aligned with the City's unrepresented management classifications.
PSEA reviewed the City's justification and concurred with the proposed removal of the Deputy City Clerk classification from its bargaining unit and placement within the unrepresented management group.
This modification would provide a more appropriate alignment between the classification's responsibilities, organizational role, and employment structure.
4. Compensation Review and Market Competitiveness
Human Resources also evaluated the Deputy City Clerk's compensation relative to comparable positions in neighboring municipalities. The review considered the varying levels of responsibility, education, experience, organizational structure, and management expectations associated with comparable positions. Additionally, the City's evaluation identified a need to realign the compensation of the Deputy City Clerk classification to reflect the expanded management responsibilities, increased qualifications, and competitive labor market. Based on the review, the City's current salary range was approximately 33% below the surveyed market benchmarks at the minimum, median, and maximum salary levels. Based on these findings, Human Resources recommends establishing a revised monthly salary range of $8,968 to $12,018, equivalent to $107,616 to $144,216 annually. The proposed range places the classification within the City's targeted competitive corridor of 95% to 105% of the surveyed market benchmarks.
This proposed salary structure is intended to provide appropriate compensation for the position's responsibilities while supporting the City's ability to attract and retain qualified candidates with the necessary municipal government experience and professional expertise.
Basis for Recommendation
The proposed revisions are recommended to ensure that the Deputy City Clerk classification accurately reflects the position's current responsibilities and supports the effective administration of the City Clerk's Office. Updating the classification specification will provide greater clarity regarding the position's duties, authority, accountability, and professional expectations. It will also establish an appropriate foundation for recruitment, employee performance evaluation, and long-term organizational planning.
The recommended FLSA designation reflects the position's increased administrative responsibilities and the level of independent judgment expected in managing assigned programs and statutory functions. Similarly, the proposed change in bargaining unit representation recognizes the classification's management responsibilities and community of interest with other unrepresented management positions.
Importantly, the City engaged PSEA throughout the process, provided a detailed written justification, addressed questions and concerns, and obtained the Union's concurrence with the proposed modifications. The proposed changes represent a reasonable and necessary modernization of the classification rather than the establishment of a new position. They are intended to align the Deputy City Clerk classification with operational expectations, support organizational continuity, and promote effective service delivery.
For these reasons, staff recommends that the City Council approve the proposed revisions through adoption of the accompanying resolution.
The proposed action involves an existing authorized position within the City Clerk's Office and will not increase the City's authorized full-time equivalent (FTE) position count.
The proposed salary range for the Deputy City Clerk classification is $8,968 to $12,018 per month, or $107,616 to $144,216 annually. The Deputy City Clerk position was budgeted at $92,062 for the current fiscal year. The estimated salary savings resulting from the position becoming vacant on September 20, 2026, are approximately $26,211. These savings will offset the additional costs associated with increasing the position’s salary range, resulting in a cost-neutral impact for FY 2026–27. Therefore, Budget and Finance will consider the salary increase when preparing the FY 2027-28 Budget.
