Logo

City Council
Agenda Report

ITEM NO. 23
 
 
DATE:
November 18, 2026
 
FROM:
Todd Hileman, City Manager
 
PREPARED BY:

Julian Lee, Director of Public Works

Joseph Cisneros, Deputy Director of Public Works

Anteneh Tesfaye, Water Operations Manager

 
SUBJECT:

CONSIDERATION TO APPROVE THE PURCHASE OF TWO (2) FORKLIFTS FROM CROWN LIFT TRUCKS FOR PUBLIC WORKS OPERATIONS UTLIZING THE SOURCEWELL COOPERATIVE PURCHASING PROGRAM 

 

Recommendation

It is recommended that the City Council:

  1. Review and discuss the three proposed purchasing options for two forklifts to support Public Works operations at Mission Yard and Garfield Reservoir, with estimated costs ranging from $120,237.42 to $158,744.54;
  2. Select and approve a preferred purchasing option, subject to applicable regulatory requirements and City policies;
  3. Authorize the necessary additional appropriations of up to $38,744.54, depending on the option selected; and
  4. Authorize the City Manager to execute the necessary purchase agreements and related documents with Crown Lift Trucks.
 
Executive Summary

The Public Works Department seeks City Council direction and approval to purchase two forklifts for Mission Yard and Garfield Reservoir to replace inoperable equipment and improve operational efficiency and safety. There are three purchasing options through Crown Lift Trucks: (1) two propane-powered forklifts for $120,237.42; (2) one electric and one propane-powered forklift for $139,490.98; and (3) two electric forklifts for $158,744.54.

 

The FY 2026–27 Adopted Budget includes $120,000 that is available for this purchase, requiring additional funding of up to to $38,744.54, depending on the option selected.

 
Background

The City's existing forklift (1) at Mission Yard was purchased in the late 1990s and is no longer operational and beyond repair, necessitating replacement. Staff recommends purchasing two new forklifts, each with a lifting capacity of 5,000 pounds, to provide dedicated equipment at Mission Yard and Garfield  Reservoir. This will allow both facilities to independently receive deliveries, improve operational efficiency, and safely handle materials without relying on shared equipment.

 
Analysis

The Public Works Department utilizes forklifts as a critical piece of equipment to support daily operations, including receiving deliveries and loading, unloading, moving, and storing equipment, materials, and supplies necessary for maintaining the City's infrastructure and public facilities.  The current forklift is beyond repair, causing City staff to spend a significant amount of time manually lifting smaller loads that could be completed in a fraction of the time, and more safely, using a forklift.

 

Procurement Process

To identify suitable replacements, Public Works staff coordinated with Crown Lift Trucks to evaluate equipment options, specifications, and pricing. On September 16, 2026, Crown representatives conducted an on-site assessment of the City's operational needs at Garfield Yard. Following the assessment, Crown Lift Trucks provided formal quotations on September 23, 2026, for an electric and propane-powered forklifts utilizing Sourcewell cooperative purchasing pricing.  

 

Staff evaluated two forklift models, each with a 5,000-pound lifting capacity, and obtained quotations through Sourcewell Contract No. 053024-CRO. The City’s Purchasing Ordinance (Section 2.99-29(19) expressly authorizes procurement through cooperative purchasing, such as the purchasing cooperative at Sourcewell.  Cooperative purchasing provides competitive pricing and reduces administrative costs. This approach uses an existing competitively solicited contract, streamlining procurement.

 

Crown C-5 Propane-Powered Forklift: The Crown C-5 is a CARB-compliant, propane-powered pneumatic-tire forklift that supports extended operations through quick refueling without dedicated charging infrastructure. It includes a catalytic muffler to meet applicable emissions requirements but still produces combustion-related emissions. Propane has lower CO2 emissions per unit of fuel energy than gasoline; however, the Crown C-5's actual emissions depend on fuel consumption, operating conditions, and engine emissions controls.

 

Crown CB25X-7 Electric Forklift: A battery-electric pneumatic-tire forklift that produces no on-site exhaust emissions and supports the City's transition toward zero-emission equipment. The electric model requires compatible charging infrastructure and sufficient charging time. The Garfield facility has an existing dedicated 240-volt electrical outlet that may accommodate the equipment.

 

Both models would meet the Department's anticipated lifting capacity requirements. Staff evaluated three purchasing options based on acquisition costs, operational flexibility, infrastructure requirements, and environmental considerations.

 

Option 1 – Two Propane-Powered Forklifts

Purchase two Crown C-5 propane-powered forklifts for the Mission and Garfield facilities. This option offers the lowest initial acquisition cost, standardized maintenance and fueling procedures, and operational flexibility without requiring charging infrastructure.

 

Although propane is a cleaner-burning alternative to conventional gasoline and diesel, it continues to produce combustion-related emissions. The City's Fleet Replacement Policy prioritizes zero-emission equipment but allows exceptions based on documented operational needs, infrastructure limitations, equipment suitability, and lifecycle costs. Given the cost savings and operational benefits, this option may warrant consideration under the City's exception process.

 

Option 2 – One Electric and One Propane-Powered Forklift

Purchase one Crown CB25X-7 electric forklift for the Garfield facility and one Crown C-5 propane-powered forklift for the Mission facility. This option balances operational flexibility with the introduction of zero-emission equipment. 

 

Option 3 – Two Electric Forklifts

Purchase two Crown CB25X-7 electric forklifts, one for each facility. This option provides the greatest environmental benefit by eliminating on-site exhaust emissions and supporting the City's zero-emission equipment objectives. However, it has the highest cost and may require additional electrical infrastructure at the Mission facility.

 

The proposed purchase costs are summarized below:

 

Description Option 1: Two Propane Option 2: Electric + Propane Option 3: Two Electric
Electric forklift(s) – CB25X-7 — $79,372.27 $158,744.54
Propane forklift(s) – C-5 $120,237.42 $59,330.99 —
Total Purchase Cost $120,237.42 $139,490.98 $158,744.54
Adopted Budget $100,000.00 $100,000.00 $100,000.00
Additional Funding Required $20,237.42 $39,490.98 $58,744.54

Costs include equipment options, applicable sales tax, freight, and optional maintenance services. Options 1 and 3 assume the quoted unit prices apply to two identical forklifts and are subject to vendor confirmation. Additional charging infrastructure costs, if required, are not included.

 

The electric forklift requires an additional upfront investment of $19,253.56 per unit compared with the propane model, using adjusted package totals. The updated quotes do not specify delivery dates. Previously reported estimates were February 2027 for electric and April 2027 for propane; staff must obtain updated delivery commitments before issuing purchase orders. 

 

Staff recommends that the City Council review the proposed forklift purchasing options, select and approve a preferred option, and provide direction regarding the allocation of funds necessary to complete the purchase.

 
Fiscal Impact

The City's FY 2026–27 Adopted Budget includes $120,000 available for the replacement of two forklifts, allocated as follows:

Fund Account Budget
General Fund (101) 101-6010-6601-8540-000 $5,000
Facilities Maintenance Fund (105) 105-6010-6601-8540-000 $10,000
Sewer Enterprise Fund (210) 210-6010-6501-8540-000 $30,000
State Gas Tax Fund (230) 230-6010-6116-8540-000 $15,000
Water Enterprise Fund (500) 500-6010-6710-8540-000 $60,000
Total   $120,000

The additional funding required would depend on the option selected:

  • Option 1 – Two Propane: No additional funding necessary.
  • Option 2 – One Electric and One Propane: $19,490.98
  • Option 3 – Two Electric: $38,744.54

 

Pending direction regarding Options 2 or 3, staff will recommend budget transfers from other funding sources during the mid-year budget review to cover the cost.

 

Estimated annual operating and maintenance costs are $5,000 for the propane forklift and $2,500 for the electric forklift, excluding battery replacement if needed. These expenses will be funded through the Department’s applicable operating budgets. Any electrical infrastructure improvements would be evaluated separately.

 
Attachment:
Attachment No. 1 - Electric Forklift - Sourcewell Quote
Attachment No. 2 - Propane Forklift - Sourcewell Quote