Erika Ramirez, Community Development Director
CONSIDERATION TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 8038 ADOPTING A SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENT TO AMEND THE DOWNTOWN SPECIFIC PLAN TO ESTABLISH OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS AND MAKE ASSOCIATED AMENDMENTS; AND HOLD FIRST READING OF ORDINANCE NO. 2423, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SOUTH PASADENA AMENDING SECTION 36.410.040 OF ARTICLE 4 (ZONING APPROVAL PROCEDURES) AND SECTION 36.700.020(O) OF ARTICLE 7 (DEFINITIONS) OF CHAPTER 36 (ZONING) OF THE
SOUTH PASADENA MUNICIPAL CODE TO APPLY THE DOWNTOWN SPECIFIC PLAN (DTSP) OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS (ODS) SET FORTH IN C10 (OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS) OF THE DTSP TO PROJECTS THAT QUALIFY FOR MINISTERIAL DESIGN REVIEW AND MAKING A DETERMINATION OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA GUIDELINES SECTIONS 15061(B)(3) AND 15060(C)(3) AND GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 65912.160(C)(2)
It is recommended that the City Council:
- Conduct a public hearing;
- Adopt Resolution No. 8038 adopting a Specific Plan Amendment to amend the Downtown Specific Plan (DTSP) to establish objective design standards and make associated amendments (Attachment 1); and
- Introduce and waive full reading of Ordinance No. 2423 amending Chapter 36 (Zoning) of the South Pasadena Municipal Code to incorporate objective design standards into design review, apply the DTSP Objective Design Standards to qualifying residential projects subject to ministerial design review, and add a definition of “objective design standard” (Attachment 2).
The proposed amendments would establish objective design standards (ODS) for qualifying residential and mixed-use development within the Downtown Specific Plan (DTSP) area and integrate those standards into the City’s design review procedures. ODS provide measurable, verifiable requirements that communicate design expectations and allow consistent review without personal or subjective judgment.
Resolution No. 8038 would add Chapter C10, Objective Design Standards, to the DTSP and make associated amendments. The standards address building form, façade composition, architectural details, materials, shading, and relationships to historic resources through two architectural pathways: American Mercantile and Spanish Colonial Revival. Ordinance No. 2423 would incorporate ODS into the Zoning Code’s design review provisions, define “objective design standard,” and apply the DTSP ODS as interim requirements for qualifying residential projects outside the DTSP that are subject to ministerial design review. The amendments would not change permitted land uses, allowable density, building height, or setbacks.
The proposed standards were developed through community engagement and reviewed by the ODS Subcommittee, Planning Commission, and City Council. Following a public hearing on October 20, 2026, the Planning Commission voted 4–1 to recommend approval. Staff recommends that the City Council adopt Resolution No. 8038 and introduce Ordinance No. 2423. Phase 2 would establish standards for applicable development elsewhere in the City, prioritizing residential areas affected by SB 79, with completion anticipated in March 2027.
December 17, 2025: The City Council approved an agreement with Torti Gallas + Partners (TGP), following a competitive selection process, to prepare Objective Design Standards for multifamily and mixed-use development. Work began in January 2026.
March 2026: Initial engagement included focus groups with design professionals, residents, and youth; a community walk on March 14; and an online survey. Recurring themes included building scale and massing, pedestrian-oriented frontages, materials, landscaping and neighborhood compatibility.
April 8, 2026: At a joint study session, the City Council and Planning Commission directed staff to proceed with a framework addressing building types, frontage types, articulation and massing, architectural standards, architectural styles, and landscaping, with emphasis on Mission Street.
June 9, 2026: The Planning Commission received and filed an ODS update.
July 7, 2026: The City Council established an advisory ODS Subcommittee consisting of two Councilmembers and three Planning Commissioners.
July 14, 2026: The Planning Commission dissolved its ODS/Accessory Dwelling Unit Ad Hoc Subcommittee and established a new ADU Ad Hoc Subcommittee.
July 22, 2026: The ODS Subcommittee began meeting with staff and TGP.
September 2, 2026: The City Council approved a First Amendment to the consultant agreement, revising the scope to a two-phase approach to respond to the priority of the downtown area.
September 3, 2026: The ODS Subcommittee provided direction on the Phase 1 timeline, design topics, and document format.
September 8, 2026: The Planning Commission reviewed the phasing plan, proposed outline and design topics considered by the Subcommittee.
October 7, 2026: The City Council and Planning Commission held a joint study session to review the draft DTSP ODS.
October 20, 2026: Following a duly noticed public hearing, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 26-14 by a 4–1 vote, recommending that the City Council adopt Resolution No. 8038 and introduce for first reading and subsequently adopt Ordinance No. 2423.
The City of South Pasadena’s design review process has historically relied on design criteria that require interpretation and judgment by staff and the Planning Commission. The City does not currently have a comprehensive set of Objective Design Standards (ODS) for multifamily and mixed-use development. This creates a gap in the City’s design review framework, particularly for qualifying projects that are eligible for ministerial review, which evaluates compliance with established requirements without discretionary design review.
ODS are measurable and verifiable requirements that applicants and staff can understand before an application is submitted and apply consistently without personal or subjective judgment. They create specific requirements for features such as building form, façade articulation, architectural details, and materials. Establishing these standards would communicate design expectations to applicants and provide staff with a defined basis for evaluating project compliance.
The proposed Specific Plan and Zoning Text Amendments would establish ODS for applicable development within the DTSP and provide interim design requirements for qualifying ministerial residential projects outside the DTSP. The standards are intended to reflect South Pasadena’s architectural character while accommodating development allowed by applicable regulations and State law. They would operate with existing zoning and Specific Plan requirements, as amended, without changing permitted land uses, allowable density, or building height.
The City entered into an agreement with Torti Gallas + Partners (TGP) to develop the proposed standards through community engagement, review of existing regulations and precedent standards, and consideration of direction from the City Council, Planning Commission, and ODS Subcommittee. Initial engagement included focus groups with design professionals, residents, and youth; a community walk; and an online survey. Feedback addressed building scale and massing, pedestrian-oriented frontages, materials, landscaping, and neighborhood compatibility. These topics informed the framework presented at the April 8, 2026 joint City Council and Planning Commission kick off study session.
Subcommittee Direction and Commission and Council Feedback
The ODS Subcommittee, consisting of two Councilmembers and three Planning Commissioners, began meeting weekly with staff and TGP on July 22, 2026. The Subcommittee prioritized Mission Street and Fair Oaks Avenue, selected the DTSP as the Phase 1 boundary and regulatory framework, and directed the use of American Mercantile and Spanish Colonial Revival architectural pathways. Pasadena’s high-density housing ODS provided a starting point, with modifications for South Pasadena’s context. TGP prepared a matrix documenting precedent standards, examples, consultant recommendations, Subcommittee direction, and Planning Commission feedback.
Following Planning Commission review on September 8, 2026, the consulting team added standards addressing historic resources and development adjacent to historic resources. These provisions were included in the draft reviewed at the October 7, 2026 joint City Council and Planning Commission study session. The Commission also discussed using primary and secondary street classifications instead of cardinal directions for building orientation and adding architectural pathways; these discussions did not result in revisions.
Table 1 summarizes topics discussed at the October 7, 2026 joint study session and resulting revisions or clarifications presented to the Planning Commission on October 20, 2026.
Table 1- Summary of Study Session Revisions and Clarifications
| Topic | Type | Result |
| Landmark and Historic Resource | Revision | Terminology was aligned with the Municipal Code. The proposed setback requirement for development adjacent to historic resources was reduced to 5 feet, and the encroachment plane was removed. |
| Shading - requirements and reference date and time | Revision and clarification | The shading calculation reference month changed from June to August to better reflect Southern California conditions. Required shading elements establish minimum requirements; additional shading may be provided. |
| Applicability | Revision | Square-footage thresholds replaced valuation or fair-market-value thresholds to align with the Zoning Code’s nonconforming provisions. |
| Variances or Modifications | Clarification | The DTSP allows for special exceptions, but these are limited to building placement, lot size, building types and frontage types. The draft ODS was NOT modified to allow for variances or modifications from ODS because it was determined that providing an alternatively discretionary process removes the predictability and introduces subjectivity which is in conflict with the intent of the State expectations of providing predictability in development for applicants. It would also be in conflict with the definition of objective design standards itself set by the State. All projects that meet the applicability thresholds will be required to comply with the ODS. |
| Shopfront/ Ground floor retail | Clarification | The ODS supplement existing DTSP shopfront overlay and ground-floor retail requirements with standards for glazing and floor-to-ceiling heights. |
| Architectural Pathways |
Clarification |
While the draft standards are organized into 2 architectural pathways, each pathway allows for variation that may result in a more modern looking building. |
Additional revisions clarified references, terminology and diagrams.
Specific Plan Amendment
Resolution No. 8038 would amend DTSP Part C to add Chapter C10, Objective Design Standards, and make associated amendments, including renumbering to C11 Administration and C12 Definitions, as shown in Exhibits A through D attached to the Resolution.
The standards address building massing and articulation; the design of building bases, middle portions, and tops; window placement and the proportion of openings to solid walls; architectural elements; materials and colors; and shading. Applicants would select the American Mercantile or Spanish Colonial Revival pathway and demonstrate compliance with its measurable standards and all generally applicable requirements.
Within the DTSP, the ODS would apply to new townhouse, multifamily, residential condominium, and mixed-use projects containing residential units, as well as improvements to existing multifamily or mixed-use development that meet the specified demolition, alteration, or addition thresholds. Single-family dwellings, accessory dwelling units, junior accessory dwelling units, nonresidential development, and specified maintenance and repair activities would be exempt. The proposed applicability provisions also account for cumulative modifications over a three-year period to prevent phased improvements from avoiding the compliance thresholds.
Zoning Text Amendment
Ordinance No. 2423 would amend SPMC Section 36.410.040 to incorporate objective design standards into the purposes of design review and the applicable findings. It would also revise subsection D.4 to require a limited review of qualifying ministerial projects for compliance with DTSP Chapter C10 Objective Design Standards and other applicable standards. These amendments would integrate ODS into the design review process and provide interim design requirements for qualifying ministerial residential projects outside the DTSP until Phase 2 is completed.
The ordinance would also add a definition of “Objective Design Standard” to Division 36.700. The proposed definition describes standards that require no personal or subjective judgment, are uniformly verifiable against external, objective benchmarks, and may be applied through ministerial review.
Specific Plan and Zoning Text Amendment Required Findings
South Pasadena Municipal Code (SPMC) Section 36.620.070(B) establishes the required findings for Zoning Code amendments, and SPMC Section 36.440.070(C) establishes the required findings for Specific Plan amendments. The following analysis supports the required findings for the proposed amendments.
General Plan and Specific Plan Consistency
The proposed Specific Plan Amendment is consistent with General Plan Policy P3.2 and Actions A3.2a and A3.2b, which direct growth to Downtown and support mixed-use, walkable development. Policy P3.4 and Actions A3.4a and A3.4b support conservation of the City’s character and scale through buildings that engage the street and complement its architectural and cultural traditions. The standards implement this direction through measurable requirements for building form, façade composition, and the relationship between buildings and the public realm.
The proposed Specific Plan Amendment is also consistent with DTSP Policy P3.1 and Actions A3.1a and A3.1b; Policy P3.2 and Action A3.2a; and Policy P3.5 and Actions A3.5a and A3.5b. These provisions support contextual infill, buildings that frame and activate streets, pedestrian-oriented development, streamlined review, and a diverse housing supply.
The proposed ordinance is consistent with General Plan Policy P3.1 and Action A3.1a, which support development regulations that maintain and enhance established neighborhood character, and Policy P3.5 and Action A3.5a, which support a form-based code for Downtown and objective design standards outside Downtown. Both amendments also support Housing Element Goal 3.0 and Program 3.n by providing a predictable design review framework for housing development.
Public Interest and Welfare
The proposed Zoning Text Amendment would support the public interest, health, safety, convenience, and general welfare by establishing clear design requirements and a transparent basis for evaluating compliance. The standards guide the relationship between buildings, neighboring properties, and the public realm. Individual projects would remain subject to applicable building, fire, accessibility, and other health and safety requirements.
Internal Zoning Code Consistency
The proposed Zoning Text Amendment integrates objective design standards into the existing design review framework and supports the Zoning Code’s purposes of orderly development, neighborhood character, compatibility, and pedestrian orientation. The standards would operate with applicable zoning and Specific Plan requirements, subject to State housing laws governing approvals, density bonuses, incentives, concessions, and waivers.
The proposed amendments would establish a measurable design framework for qualifying development, implement General Plan and DTSP policies, and provide interim standards for qualifying ministerial residential projects outside Downtown. Together, the amendments would support consistent application review while guiding building design to reflect South Pasadena’s architectural character. Phase 2 would extend this framework to applicable development elsewhere in the City.
ODS Next Steps
If introduced on November 18, 2026, Ordinance No. 2423 would be scheduled for second reading and adoption on December 2, 2026, with an anticipated effective date of January 1, 2027. Implementation of the DTSP amendments would follow the effective-date provisions of Resolution No. 8038 and any coordination provisions in the ordinance.
Phase 2 would begin following completion of Phase 1 and address applicable multifamily and mixed-use development elsewhere in the City. Subphase 2A would prioritize residential areas affected by SB 79, followed by Subphase 2B for the remaining applicable areas. Phase 2 is anticipated to be completed by March 2027.
Alternatively, the City Council may continue the item and provide direction to staff as appropriate.
The ODS project budget is included in Account No. 101-7010-7011-8170-000 (Professional Services) in the Community Development Department’s FY 2026–2027 Adopted Budget. Preparation and implementation of the amendments are part of the ODS work program. The proposed action does not authorize a construction project or capital expenditure.
The proposed amendments advance Strategic Plan Item No. 5—Plan for Affordable Housing to Comply with State Mandates and Respond to Community Needs. Clear, measurable design requirements support housing production and predictable review while guiding development that responds to South Pasadena’s neighborhood character.
Following a duly noticed public hearing on October 20, 2026, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 26-14 by a 4–1 vote, recommending that the City Council adopt Resolution No. 8038 and introduce for first reading and subsequently adopt Ordinance No. 2423.
Commission comments primarily addressed revisions to text and diagrams to improve consistency and clarity. The Commission also recommended accounting for cumulative building modifications over a three-year period to prevent phased improvements from avoiding ODS compliance thresholds. This provision is included in the proposed standards presented to the City Council. A couple of Commissioners continued to express concerns about the limited number of architectural pathways; however, no changes to the pathways are proposed.
A public notice for this Public Hearing was published in the South Pasadena Review on October 30, 2026. The public was also made aware of the regularly scheduled Public Hearing on November 12, 2026 through its inclusion in the legally publicly noticed agenda, posted physically at City Hall and also on the City’s website.
The proposed amendments are exempt from CEQA pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15061(b)(3), consistent with the common sense exemption stated in the supplied ordinance and resolution. The amendments establish objective design requirements and clarify their application. They do not change permitted land uses, increase allowable density or height, or authorize construction of a specific development project. Future development proposals would be reviewed under applicable environmental requirements.
