Logo

City Council
Agenda Report

ITEM NO. 7
 
 
DATE:
November 18, 2026
 
FROM:
Todd Hileman, City Manager
 
PREPARED BY:

Erika Ramirez, Community Development Director

 

Michael Donovan, Associate Planner

 
SUBJECT:

CONSIDERATION OF APPROVAL OF A MILLS ACT CONTRACT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 220 ORANGE GROVE AVENUE.

 

Recommendation

It is recommended that City Council City Council review the proposed Rehabilitation and Restoration Work Plan and approve a Mills Act Contract with the property owner of 220 Orange Grove Avenue.

 
Executive Summary

The property owners of 220 Orange Grove Avenue request a Mills Act contract to support preservation of their 1913  Mission Revival/Craftsman/Prairie style single-family dwelling listed in the California Register of Historical Resources. The proposed Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan ("work plan") identifies seven rehabilitation projects totaling $450,800 which includes addressing drainage and water-management deficiencies, basement and structural repairs, whole system upgrades, and other weather exposed elements. Completion dates range from 2027 to 2035.

 

On August 20, 2026, the Cultural Heritage Commission (CHC) voted 4-0 to recommend approval.

 
Background

On March 11, 2026, a letter of intent to submit a Mills Act application for the property located at 220 Orange Grove Avenue was filed with the City. 

 

On March 19, 2026, the letter of intent was presented to the Cultural Heritage Commission and a subcommittee was appointed to review the request in further detail. Chair Severson and Commissioner Lopez were appointed to the subcommittee. 

 

On April 16, 2026, the Subcommittee and staff conducted an on-site visit to inspect the condition of the property.

 

On May 26, 2026, a formal Mills Act application (Attachment 1) was filed by the Applicant.

 

On June 30, 2026, the Cultural Heritage Commission reviewed the Mills Act application and associated work plan for 220 Orange Grove Ave. 

 

On August 20, 2026, the Cultural Heritage Commission recommended approval of the Mills Act contract to City Council. 

 
Analysis

Constructed in 1913, the two-story Mission Revival/Craftsman/Prairie style single-family dwelling located at 220 Orange Grove Avenue is listed in the California Register with a California Historical Resource Status Code of 2S (Individually determined eligible for National Register by the Keeper. Listed in the California Register). Pursuant to SPMC Section 2.68(b)(1)(B) Limitations on Eligibility, Mills Act contracts are limited to the following qualifying properties: landmarks; contributing properties of local historic districts; properties listed on the National Register; properties listed on the California Register; and properties that the commission, with concurrence of the city council, may identify as appropriate for a Mills Act contract. The property is eligible for a Mills Act contract because it is listed in the California Register.

 

Character-defining features include a broad front veranda, deep overhanging roof eaves, and wood windows with trim. The proposed work plan is intended to rehabilitate and repair the historic resource while improving drainage, structural stability, and building safety.

 

A Mills Act contract provides a property tax incentive in exchange for the owner's commitment to preserve a qualifying historic property and complete an approved Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan ("work plan"). The agreement incorporates the approved scope, completion dates, and reporting requirements as enforceable obligations. Contract approval does not replace required permits or Certificates of Appropriateness.  

 

Proposed Scope of Work: 

The Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan ("work plan") prepared by Wan Kwan Mai and Hin Shing Mai ("Applicants") documents the home's condition, identifying chronic drainage and moisture-management deficiencies, deterioration of the utility basement area, obsolete or deficient whole-house mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems, and deterioration of the exterior wood, trim, porch/veranda, and other weather related exposed elements. Table 1 summarizes the rehabilitation projects and their preservation purpose. Costs are applicant estimates rather than fixed construction prices. 

 

The schedule prioritizes drainage and water-management deficiencies in the first couple years, followed by basement and structural repairs, whole system upgrades, and then addressing weather exposed elements. All projects are scheduled and required to be completed within the first ten years of the proposed contract. Any treatments shall follow the Secretary of Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 1 - Summary of Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan

Proposed Scope of Work Estimated Cost Estimated Year for Completion
1. Roof and deck water management improvements. Address roof and deck drainage conditions, repair or replace failed coverings as needed for continued restoration and protection of roof, and related weatherproofing. $ 60,000 2027
2.    Site drainage, grading, downspout, and perimeter water-management improvements necessary to address drainage issues around site that contribute to damage of structure.  $ 45,000 2028
3.    Utility basement retaining wall, slab, waterproofing, and related structural repair. $ 125,000 2030
4.    Whole-house HVAC rehabilitation and duct replacement. $ 60,000 2031
5.    Whole-house electrical modernization. $ 55,000 2032
6.    Whole-house plumbing rehabilitation and sewer replacement. $ 55,800 2033
7.    Exterior wood, trim, porch/veranda, and weather exposed feature repair. $ 50,000 2035
Total proposed rehabilitation investment $ 450,800 2026-2036

 

 

Evaluation of Mills Act crtieria

SPMC Section 2.68(b)(1)(C) establishes six criteria for evaluating a proposed Mills Act contract, which are: (1) financial investment; (2) public benefit; (3) retroactive limitations; (4) maintenance work limitations; (5) interior work limitations; and (6) landscape work limitations. The Cultural Heritage Commission considered the listed criteria in their evaluation of the Work Plan and accepted the analysis below as basis for the recommendation to the City Council for approval of the Mills Act contract for 220 Orange Grove Avenue.

 

Criterion (i) Financial Investment. The estimated tax benefit is not expected to exceed the applicant’s proposed financial investment in the cultural resource over the first 10 years of the contract.  

 

The applicant is proposing to invest approximately $450,800 in qualified repairs and restoration over the first ten years of the Mills Act contract. The tax benefit over the same period is expected to be $335,987.  Thus, the estimated tax benefit is not expected to exceed the applicant’s proposed financial investment in the cultural resource over the first ten years of the contract. The financial analysis is included in the Mills Act Application under Exhibit B of Attachment 1.  Therefore, criterion (i) is met.

 

Criterion (ii) Public Benefit. The proposed Mills Act contract features a work plan that will provide a benefit to the public by: rehabilitating the property for continued occupancy or adaptive reuse; improved viability through systems upgrades and structural reinforcement upgrades; preserving and maintaining the character-defining features of the property, and/or restoring character-defining features of the property that have been significantly altered or removed over time.  

 

The home was built in 1913 and shows areas in need of repair. The property shows signs of major drainage and moisture-management deficiencies; deterioration in the utility basement with water accumulation, concrete wall spalling; roof and deck water intrusions; obsolete and deficient whole-house mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and sewer systems; interior deterioration of the plaster walls, fireplace, and wood floors; and exterior deterioration of the wood, trim, porch/veranda, and other weather related-exposed components. Drainage and ponding issues will be addressed at the roof, basement, and other hardscape and deck areas. The utility basement will need repairs to the retaining wall and concrete slab for structural stability. Complete system upgrades including electrical, mechanical, and plumbing will be addressed to improve safety and viability of the resource. The exterior wood, trim, and concrete porch will be repaired and restored to protect its character-defining features. Therefore, criterion (ii) is met.

 

Criterion (iii) Retroactive Limitations. The estimated tax benefit will not be used for any maintenance or alteration work that was previously completed or initiated before the contract is approved, unless it can be shown that the completed work was necessary in the interest of the public health or safety following involuntary damage or destruction caused by fire, act of nature, or any other casualty.  

 

No previous work has been completed or initiated. Therefore, Criterion (iii) is met.

 

Criterion (iv) Limitations on Maintenance. The estimated tax benefit will not be used for routine maintenance work except for exemplary or exceptional properties that have financially burdensome maintenance requirements.

 

The estimated tax benefit will not be used for maintenance work, therefore, criterion (iv) is met.

 

Criterion (v) Limitations on Interior Work. The estimated tax benefit will not be used for work within the interior of a cultural resource unless the commission determines the following exceptions should be made: the interior work is necessary to improve the structural integrity of the property; the interior work is necessary to preserve and maintain character-defining features within the cultural resource that are specifically identified as part of the official landmark nomination; and/or the interior work is necessary to preserve and maintain character-defining features of the property that were discovered subsequent to its landmark designation. The commission must first determine that those interior features are character-defining based on substantial evidence provided by the applicant.  

 

The proposed Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan does include some interior work, but it is necessary to improve the structural integrity of the property such as repairing the basement retaining wall and basement slab. The complete systems upgrade of the obsolete or deficient electrical, mechanical, and plumbing systems is also in compliance with criterion (ii). Therefore, criterion (v) is met.

 

Criterion (vi) Limitations on Landscaping. The estimated tax benefit will not be used for landscaping work unless it will be used for specific landscape features that were identified as part of the official landmark nomination.  

 

Some landscaping work includes grading and perimeter improvements, but this is in an effort to address drainage around the site which can deteriorate the exterior siding and damage the basement leading due water pooling and mold. The estimated tax benefit will not be used for any general landscape work, therefore, criterion (vi) is met. 

 
Alternatives

Alternatively, the City Council may continue the item to obtain clarification of eligible expenditures, revised financial calculation, or a revised work plan, or decline to approve the contract.

 
Fiscal Impact

The application projects approximately $335,987 in owner property tax savings during the first ten years of the contract. Based on the financial analysis provided with the application, the City’s share of the resulting property tax revenue reduction is estimated at approximately $53,758 (16%) over ten years, or an annual average of approximately $5,376. The actual fiscal impact may vary based on the property’s assessed value and the valuation calculated by the Los Angeles County Assessor. 

 

The proposed rehabilitation work would be privately funded. The City's reduced property tax revenue would support a contractual preservation commitment rather than a direct City payment for construction.

 
Key Performance Indicators and Strategic Plan

Progress would be evaluated against completion of work items identified in the Rehabilitation and Restoration Plan ("work plan"). As identified in the contract, the property owner will be required to submit a progress report to staff every three years. The report will document completed and pending tasks, expenditures, photographs, and applicable permits and Certificates of Appropriateness. However, staff has implemented a monitoring program for all active Mills Act Contracts and will take a proactive approach moving forward starting with quarterly check ins with contract owners to ensure compliance in addition to the required three year progress reports. Separately, the Cultural Heritage Commission will provide an annual report to City Council on its review of all active Mills Act contracts. The agreement provides a schedule for City review and follow-up on overdue work.

 
Commission Review and Recommendation

On August 20, 2026, the Cultural Heritage Commission reviewed the Mills Act application and voted 4-0 to recommend that the City Council enter into a contract with the owners of 220 Orange Grove Avenue. The recommendation followed subcommittee review and the April 16, 2026 site visit.

 
Public Notification

The community has been notified of this consent calendar item via a posting of the agenda on the City website on November 12, 2026.

 
Environmental Analysis

In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), the project qualifies for an exemption under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15308, Class 8: Actions taken by regulatory agencies, as authorized by state or local ordinance, to assure the maintenance, restoration, enhancement, or protection of the environment where the regulatory process involves procedures for protection of the environment.  

 

Class 8 exemptions apply to actions taken by regulatory agencies, as authorized by state law or local ordinance, to assure maintenance, restoration, enhancement, or protection of the environment where the regulatory process involves procedures for environmental protection. The Mills Act contract is a regulatory tool to promote the preservation of historical resources. Approval of the contract will result in the long-term protection and maintenance of a designated historic resource, contributing to the preservation of the City’s cultural and architectural environment. There are no unusual circumstances that would result in a significant environmental impact.

 
Attachment:
Attachment No. 1 - Mills Act Contract__220 Orange Grove Avenue_Draft
Attachment No. 1 - Exhibit A - Legal Description
Attachment No. 1 - Exhibit B - Mills Act Application