Nick Kimball, Assistant City Manager/CFO
William Castrillon, Budget and Finance Manager
CONSIDERATION TO APPROVE A PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH HINDERLITER DE LLAMAS & ASSOCIATES FOR BUSINESS LICENSE ADMINISTRATION AND SOFTWARE HOSTING SERVICES
It is recommended that the City Council:
- Waive formal bidding process and approve a five-year Professional Services Agreement with Hinderliter de Llamas & Associates (HDL) to provide business license administration and related software hosting services in an amount not to exceed $400,000 based on recent formal competitive solicitations by other cities for similar services.
- Authorize the City Manager, or designee, to execute the Professional Services Agreement with HDL.
Staff recommends that the City Council approve a new five-year agreement with Hinderliter de Llamas & Associates (HDL) for business license administration and related software hosting services in an amount not to exceed $400,000. As part of the procurement evaluation, City staff reviewed recently competitively solicited contracts awarded to HDL by the Cities of Ojai and Roseville for comparable services. These agreements provided additional reference points for assessing HDL's qualifications, service capabilities, and pricing to ensure the City is receiving service at a competitive price.
The City has maintained a contractual relationship with HDL since 2018, with subsequent amendments extending the existing agreement through October 2026. In addition to business license administration, HDL provides the City with Utility Users Tax management, Sales, Use and Transaction Tax audit services, and Property Tax consulting and auditing services.
The proposed agreement allows the City to maintain its existing business license administration platform and services while ensuring continuity of operations. The five-year agreement represents an average annual cost of approximately $80,000, which is generally consistent with the City's historical expenditures, while accounting for anticipated Consumer Price Index (CPI) increases.
On November 18, 2018, the City initially entered into an agreement with Hinderliter de Llamas and Associates (HDL) for $39,000 annually for the provision of services, with an initial contract extending through October 2021.
In January 2022, the City Council approved the first amendment in the amount of $40,950, extending the contract through October 2023.
In September 2023, the City Council approved the second amendment in the amount of $75,000 and extended the contract through October 2024.
In November 2024, the City Council approved a Third Amendment in the amount of $122,300 and extended the agreement through October 2026. Although the $122,300 represented the cost of one year of services, the contract extension covered a two-year period.
Many California cities contract with specialized firms to administer their business license tax programs because the work takes dedicated staff, specialized technology, and technical expertise that are hard to maintain in-house. These firms handle registration and annual renewals, billing and payment processing, customer service, delinquency follow-up, and collection and remittance of the State disability access (SB 1186) fee, so municipal staff can focus on core finance functions. Contract administrators also provide online portals for applications and payments. They use third-party data sources, including state tax and licensing records, to identify businesses that are operating without a license or under-reporting gross receipts, which helps the tax be applied consistently and fairly to all businesses. The City currently contracts with HdL Companies (HdL) for business license tax administration.
Procurement Process
To evaluate the proposed agreement, City staff reviewed two recently awarded contracts for similar services that were competitively solicited and awarded to HDL by the Cities of Ojai and Roseville. These agreements provide additional reference points for evaluating HDL's qualifications, service capabilities, and pricing in relation to comparable municipal services.
| City | Management Fee | Annual CPI Increase | Discovery Fee | Collection Service Fees | Audit Service Fees |
| South Pasadena | $19.51 | 2% - 10% | 35% of Revenue | 25% of revenue | 40% of revenue |
| Roseville | $15.41 | 2% - 10% | 35% of Revenue | 25% of revenue | 35% of revenue |
| Ojai | $23.00 | 2% - 10% | 35% of Revenue | 25% of revenue | 40% of revenue |
The City's proposed agreement with HDL is competitively priced when compared to the agreements recently awarded by the Cities of Roseville and Ojai for similar business tax administration services. South Pasadena's proposed management fee of $19.51 falls between Roseville's fee of $15.41 and Ojai's fee of $23.00, demonstrating that the City's pricing is within the range of comparable municipal contracts. Additionally, all three agreements provide for the same annual CPI adjustment of 2% to 10%, a discovery fee of 35% of revenue, and collection service fees of 25% of revenue. South Pasadena's proposed audit service fee of 40% is consistent with Ojai's agreement and only slightly higher than Roseville's 35% fee.
Based on this comparison, HDL's proposed pricing is generally consistent with the rates negotiated by other municipalities. Staff therefore recommends proceeding with HDL as the City's business tax consultant, as the agreement provides competitive pricing and access to an experienced firm providing specialized business tax administration, collection, and compliance services to municipalities.
HdL
Founded in 1983, Hinderliter de Llamas & Associates (HdL) specializes in maximizing local government revenues through revenue allocation audits, analytical services, and proprietary software solutions. The firm provides comprehensive municipal revenue services covering business license taxes, transient occupancy (lodging) taxes, sales and use taxes, transaction and use taxes, cannabis taxes, utility users' taxes, and other locally administered revenues.
HdL maintains one of the largest privately held databases of sales, property, and business tax information in California. These proprietary data resources provide a foundation for identifying emerging economic trends, analyzing revenue performance, and developing more accurate revenue projections to support municipal budgeting and financial planning.
HdL's systematic and coordinated approach to revenue management, tax administration, and economic data analysis is currently utilized by more than 900 public agencies nationwide.
.
HDL has developed familiarity with the City's business license operations, historical records, revenue administration processes, and reporting requirements through its ongoing contractual relationship with the City. Continuing with HDL allows the City to retain its established software platform and avoid the potential administrative and operational challenges associated with transitioning to a new provider. Such a transition could require data migration, system configuration, staff training, and adjustments to existing business licensing procedures, potentially resulting in additional costs and temporary disruptions to service delivery.
Contract Amount and Cost Considerations
The proposed agreement establishes a five-year contract term with a total expenditure amount not to exceed $400,000, equivalent to an average annual cost of approximately $80,000. Based on the evaluation of the competitively bid proposals recently received by similar cities, staff recommends approving the proposed contract. If City Council approves the proposed agreement, staff will conduct a procurement review toward the end of the contract term and consider a formal request for proposal process at that time.
The proposed five-year Professional Services Agreement establishes a total expenditure limit of $400,000, or $80,000 per year. There are sufficient funds in the FY 2026/2027 budget in 101-3010-3011-8170-0000 for the current year expenses. No additional funds are needed. Expenditure for future years will be funded through the City's operating budget, subject to annual budget appropriations and the availability of funds.
