User Fee Cost Recovery Framework
Daniel Choe, Administrative Services Deputy Director
Discuss the Proposed User Fee Cost Recovery Framework and Provide Direction to Staff.
Pursuant to Rocklin Municipal Code (RMC) Chapter 3.32, the City maintains a service fee cost comparison system to recover some or all of the costs associated with providing services of a limited nature. This approach helps ensure that general taxes remain available to support services that benefit the broader community rather than subsidize services that primarily benefit specific individuals or entities.
Under RMC Chapter 3.32, the City generally seeks to recover 100% of the reasonable costs associated with providing services, including allowable direct and indirect costs. However, full cost recovery may not be practical or appropriate for every service, particularly when services provide broader community benefits or when affordability and access are important considerations. While the RMC allows the City Council to establish lower cost recovery levels, the proposed framework seeks to provide a more consistent and transparent approach to exercising that discretion. The framework is intended to balance the cost of providing services, the benefits received by individual users and the broader community, and the appropriate level of General Fund support.
To further evaluate the City's cost recovery practices and enhance its fee-setting methodology, the City released a Request for Proposals in May 2025 to select a qualified consulting firm to conduct a Comprehensive User Fee Study (Fee Study). The Fee Study is intended to evaluate the cost of providing City services, refine the City's fee-setting methodology, and incorporate a market survey of comparable jurisdictions to support a balanced approach to cost recovery. Following the competitive selection process, the City selected Government Consulting Partners, Inc. (GCP), and executed a contract on September 29, 2025.
At this time, staff is seeking direction from the City Council on cost recovery goals. The proposed User Fee Cost Recovery Framework (Attachment 1) establishes guiding principles for evaluating service fees, including applicable legal requirements, individual and community benefits, General Fund support, consistency across City services, market conditions, and other City priorities. The following summarizes the framework's key components, including its cost recovery goals and guidelines for reviewing and adjusting fees.
Cost Recovery Goals and Tiers
The proposed framework establishes three cost recovery tiers based on the nature of the benefits provided. The tiers are illustrated in the graph included in Attachment 1 and summarized below:
| Tier | Benefit Classification | Cost Recovery Goal |
|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | Primary Community Benefit | 0 - 35% |
| Tier 2 | Shared Community and Individual Benefit | 36 - 80% |
| Tier 3 | Primarily Individual Benefit | 81-100% |
Services that provide broader community benefits generally warrant greater General Fund support, while services that primarily benefit individuals generally warrant higher cost recovery through user fees. These tiers serve as guidelines rather than mandatory recovery levels, providing flexibility to consider service characteristics, applicable legal requirements, and other relevant factors when evaluating and establishing fees.
The proposed framework also establishes a consistent process for maintaining and adjusting service fees. This includes a comprehensive review every four years, annual routine reviews with adjustments based on the Employment Cost Index (ECI), and additional reviews when warranted by changes in service delivery, regulatory requirements, or other circumstances. Any fee adjustments will be subject to applicable legal requirements and City Council approval.
For fees that are materially below their applicable cost recovery goals, the framework allows increases to be phased in to balance long-term cost recovery objectives with affordability and access to services. Under this approach, annual increases would generally be limited to 50% of the then-current fee, subject to applicable legal requirements and other relevant considerations.
Staff is presenting the proposed User Fee Cost Recovery Framework to obtain City Council feedback and direction as staff finalizes the proposed service fees. Staff and GCP have recently completed a comprehensive evaluation of the City's existing fee structure, including the development of a citywide Cost Allocation Plan, calculation of fully burdened hourly rates, determination of the full cost of individual services, and assessment of existing cost recovery levels. The Fee Study project incorporated applicable direct and indirect costs, reviewed service delivery methodologies, and included a market survey of comparable jurisdictions. The results will provide a foundation for evaluating the City's fee structure and establishing appropriate cost recovery goals.
The City Council may support the framework as presented, recommend revisions, or provide alternative direction. After receiving City Council feedback, staff will finalize the framework for incorporation into the City's budget document and return to the City Council in early 2027 with next steps.
There is no fiscal impact associated with discussing and providing feedback on the proposed User Fee Cost Recovery framework. Any fiscal impacts associated with future fee adjustments will be evaluated and presented to the City Council when specific fee recommendations are brought forward for consideration.