Continued Discussion of the District's Structural Budget Deficit
Receive the expenditure analysis, continue discussion of the District’s structural budget deficit, and provide direction to staff regarding potential expenditure reductions and revenue opportunities.
Cliff Campbell, Acting Fire Chief
The Board requested that discussion of the District's structural budget deficit continue to identify ways to reduce the ongoing imbalance between revenues and expenditures. As part of this review, Director Oro requested a two-year history of expenditures to help identify the principal cost increases.
The two previous Staff Reports and their Attachments addressing the Final Budget (September 29, 2026) and the Budget Deficit (October 27, 2026) are attached. They inform the items discussed in this report. See attachments C and D.
Discussion
Staff has prepared an analysis comparing actual expenditures for FY2024-25 and FY2025-26 with the approved FY2026-27 budget, see Attachment A. The analysis includes expenditure trends and additional details on salaries, overtime, retirement contributions, employee benefits, and other operating expenses.
Salaries and benefits account for approximately 93% of the cumulative expenditure increase from FY2024-25 actual expenditures to the FY2026-27 approved Final Budget and represent 89.3% of the FY2026-27 expenditure budget.
Staff also prepared a preliminary salary, overtime, and CalPERS retirement program projection using the first eight completed payrolls of the current fiscal year to estimate the remaining eighteen payrolls. If overtime continues at the same average rate, annual overtime expenditures are projected to be $1,513,080.82, exceeding the approved $900,000 overtime budget by $613,080.82. Overtime is included within the salary projection and is not an additional expense to be added to that total. See Attachment B.
The analysis is intended to support continued Board discussion and direction. Potential staffing changes and associated savings have not been assumed and would require further evaluation, including applicable meet-and-confer requirements.
Staff is also reviewing revenue streams to assess billing, collections, and budget assumptions and identify potential opportunities. Any additional revenue identified through this review was not included in the approved Final Budget.
Staff is also reviewing expenditures to assess increases, causes, and budget assumptions and identify potential opportunities.
Use of Reserves:
The approved FY2026-27 General Operations Fund budget includes revenues of $8,415,385 and expenditures of $9,755,987, resulting in a budgeted deficit of $1,340,602. This deficit is funded through reserves. Using reserves to balance the District's budgets is unsustainable in the long term.
Cash Flow Implications:
The District's need for cash is heaviest in the first months of the fiscal year. This is due to certain payment demands for items like insurance premiums and CalPERS UAL that are received in July. The largest expense, personnel costs, tends to be spread fairly evenly over the fiscal year. The District's first large receipt of revenues is a transfer of property taxes in mid to late December. Last fiscal year, FY2025-26, the District recorded this transfer on December 17, 2025. Property taxes are collected by the County of Napa and are then transferred directly to the District.
In late October, the City of American Canyon Finance Department contacted the District to notify it that the District may experience a cash flow challenge in December 2026. Upon further cash flow analysis, City and District staff believe that the District's cash flow will be sufficient to cover the District's expenses between now and its receipt of property tax revenues from Napa County in mid to late December 2026.
The District's cash flow needs should be understood now because it is very likely this will be an issue next year too. Reserves have been serving the District as operating capital. As reserves are drawn down, having sufficient operating capital becomes a concern, and the District will need to very carefully manage its cash flow, particularly during the first six months of every fiscal year.
Overtime:
The current adopted Final Budget estimates $900,000 for overtime expenses. The District's overtime expenses for the first eight payroll periods are averaging an amount that, if projected out to the remaining eighteen payroll periods this fiscal year, would result in total overtime expenses of $1,513,080.82. This would result in overtime expenses exceeding the budget by $613,080.82. All other things being equal, this overtime overage alone would increase the General Operations Fund budget deficit from $1,340,602 to $1,953,682.82, before related employer costs.
Receiving this report does not amend the budget or authorize expenditure reductions. Staff will evaluate the fiscal effects of any options identified through Board direction and return for further consideration as appropriate.
Public Safety: "Ensure American Canyon remains a safe community"
None
