City of American Canyon Fire District Logo
AMERICAN CANYON FIRE PROTECTION DISTRICT BOARD AGENDA
OCTOBER 27, 2026

STAFF REPORT
BUSINESS
ITEM NUMBER: 9.
 


TITLE

Fiscal Year 2026-2027 Budget Deficit Review and Discussion


RECOMMENDATION

Receive a presentation on the Fiscal Year 2026–27 operating budget deficit and provide direction to staff regarding potential measures to reduce the deficit.


CONTACT

Cliff Campbell, Acting Fire Chief


BACKGROUND & ANALYSIS

During consideration and adoption of the Fiscal Year 2026–27 Final Budget at the September meeting of the Fire Board, the Board expressed concern regarding the District’s $1,340,602 Operating Fund budget deficit. The Board requested additional information regarding how the deficit developed and directed Staff to review the budget and identify potential solutions.

 

DISCUSSION
District staff is working with Regional Government Services (RGS) financial consultants Tracy Fuller and Brian Moura to review the District’s revenues, expenditures, fund balances, and reserves, as well as the financial trends impacting revenues, revenue timing, expenditures, and the District’s cash flow; and identify and the factors contributing to the operating deficit.

 

 

Deficit Analysis
Expenditures: $9,755,987
Deficit: $1,340,602
% of Operating Budget: 13.74%
Each 1% Reduction: $97,560

_____________________________

Reduction    Amount    
1%    $97,560    
2%    $195,120    
3%    $292,680    
4%    $390,239    
5%    $487,799    
6%    $585,359    
7%    $682,919    
8%    $780,479    
9%    $878,039    
10%    $975,599    
11%    $1,073,159    
12%    $1,170,718    
13%    $1,268,278    
13.74%    $1,340,602    = Operations Fund deficit
14%    $1,365,838    
15%    $1,463,398    

 

Staff are also evaluating both revenue and expenditure measures to reduce the deficit while maintaining essential services. 

 

Revenue Options
•    Fees, Charges, Other Revenues, and Interest Earnings 
While Property Tax revenues make up 81% of the District's General Operating Fund revenues ($6.8 Million in FY 2026-27), the District staff can explore and the Fire Board can approve increases in Fees and Charges (up to the cost of services), and Other Revenues including Grants. It can also explore ways to increase Interest Earnings ($677,740 or 8% of these revenues in FY 2026-27).


•    Fire Suppression Assessment (Special Tax with Voter Approval)
Another option for increasing revenue is to explore an increase in the Fire Suppression Assessment, which is currently assessed at a rate of $122.72 per Equivalent Dwelling Unit  (EDU). This assessment accounts for $945,508, or 11%, of FY 2026-27 General Operating Fund revenues. The assessment is a special tax, and any increase would require voter approval at the next General Election in November 2028.

 

Expenditure Options
•    Cost Reduction Measures
The District can also explore cost reduction measures developed by the Fire District Management Team, led by the Acting Fire Chief, for review, consideration, and approval by the Fire Board. Staffing reductions through attrition are a common cost reduction approach. The recent resignation of a Firefighter/Paramedic is expected to result in $130,156 in salary and benefit savings during FY 2026-27, before accounting for potential associated staffing and overtime costs. Staff will evaluate those costs to determine the net savings. Note that small agencies have limited capacity to redistribute workload, and some positions requiring credentials or certifications may need to remain filled. These constraints may make staffing reductions through attrition difficult to sustain.


•    Impact of Cost Reduction Measures
Cost Reduction Measures are likely to have an impact on the services that the Fire District provides. It will be important to document and consider these impacts before moving ahead with potential cost reduction measures. As an example, a reduction in force may correlate with an increase in overtime, or delayed equipment maintenance may result in a downgrade of the Fire District’s Class 2/2Y ISO rating .


•    Meet & Confer Obligations
Before some cost-reduction measures can be approved, adopted, or implemented, the District may need to meet and confer with the District’s labor representatives.

 

Tracy Fuller and Brian Moura from RGS will provide a PowerPoint presentation at the October 27th Fire Board meeting addressing the District’s financial condition, factors contributing to the deficit, and options to address the deficit. The presentation is not included in the agenda packet due to preparation timelines. 

 

Staff will receive Board feedback and continue developing recommendations, including discussions with labor representatives as appropriate. Budget adjustments requiring Board approval will be brought forward for future consideration.

__________________________________

1 EDU Definition: A standard unit of measure that represents the resource demand, water usage, or wastewater/sewer flow of a typical single-family residential home. 

2 An ISO rating is the score assigned by the Insurance Services Office (ISO) through its Public Protection Classification (PPC) system. Insurance companies use this score to help set property insurance rates for homes and businesses.  A Class 1 or Class 2 rating usually means lower insurance premiums. The ISO evaluates four primary areas: Fire Department (50%): Assesses personnel, staffing levels, training hours, response distribution, and equipment maintenance. Water Supply (40%): Evaluates the capacity, network design, and condition of fire hydrants and water flow availability. Emergency Communications (10%): Measures 911 call handling, dispatch systems, and computer-aided dispatch (CAD) infrastructure. Community Risk Reduction (Up to 5.5 extra points): Rewards fire prevention, public safety education, and code enforcement.

 


FISCAL IMPACT

This item is for discussion and direction and does not anticipate changes to the adopted FY 2026-27 Final Budget. The identified Firefighter/Paramedic vacancy is anticipated to provide $130,156 in salary and benefit savings, subject to offsetting staff costs which may be necessary to compensate for the vacancy. The fiscal impacts of additional revenue-raising and cost-saving measures will be evaluated as recommendations are developed.


BOARD PRIORITY PROGRAMS AND PROJECTS
Public Safety: "Ensure American Canyon remains a safe community"

ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW

None



ATTACHMENTS:
None